Imagine the UFC welterweight division heating up with a champion itching for a challenge that could redefine his legacy—Islam Makhachev is boldly calling for a showdown with Kamaru Usman, warning fans he's stepping up the competition big time. But here's where it gets controversial: is this the right move for the new titleholder, or is he risking it all against a fighter many say doesn't deserve the shot? Stick around as we dive into the buzz, breaking down the opinions and why this potential matchup has everyone talking.
Makhachev, fresh off claiming the 170-pound belt, has stood his ground, insisting Usman is the perfect next opponent for his first title defense. You can read more about his unwavering stance here (https://bloodyelbow.com/2025/12/10/islam-makhachev-doubles-down-on-why-he-wants-to-fight-kamaru-usman-next-despite-outrage/). Yet, with a lineup of hungry contenders vying for a crack at him, this pick has sparked plenty of backlash. Take Belal Muhammad, for instance—he's argued that Usman hasn't earned this rematch opportunity, especially after he declined other fights following his recent comeback win. Check out that heated debate here (https://bloodyelbow.com/2025/12/16/kamaru-usman-told-he-doesnt-deserve-islam-makhachev-fight-due-to-turning-down-other-matchups/).
On the flip side, a fighter who knows Usman intimately—the man himself, Jorge Masvidal—backs Makhachev's choice, calling it the toughest test out there for the champ right now. And this is the part most people miss: Masvidal's insight could flip the script on why Usman remains a nightmare for opponents.
LATEST NEWS: Paddy Pimblett calls ‘spoiled brat’ Arman Tsarukyan ‘lucky’ not to get cut from the UFC (https://bloodyelbow.com/2025/12/19/paddy-pimblett-says-spoiled-brat-arman-tsarukyan-is-lucky-to-have-not-been-cut-from-the-ufc/)
Does Usman truly merit another title shot after his impressive career highs and recent lows? How do you feel about the former champion possibly getting a rematch? Jump into the conversation below—let's hear your take!
👇 Dive into the debate; drop your thoughts. Hit the comment button on the bottom left to share your opinion.
Masvidal, a voice of experience in the MMA world, sees Usman as Makhachev's most perilous opponent at 170 pounds. He discussed this on his Death Row MMA podcast, emphasizing how it's a significant escalation from facing someone like Jack Della Maddalena. 'Gamebred,' who suffered defeats at Usman's hands, highlights the Nigerian Nightmare's elite counter-wrestling skills as a massive hurdle for Makhachev. For beginners wondering why this matters, think of wrestling as the foundation of MMA—Usman's ability to defend takedowns and scramble out of positions could turn a champion's strengths into weaknesses. Masvidal rates Della Maddalena but draws a clear line: Usman's grappling prowess, especially in defense, is on another level. 'He's a beast at wrestling defensively,' Masvidal said, suggesting this could be one of Makhachev's hardest challenges yet—and maybe not one the UFC brass will rush into.
LATEST NEWS: A former UFC champ gears up for his return by taking on three opponents at once (https://bloodyelbow.com/2025/12/19/former-ufc-champion-prepares-for-upcoming-return-by-beating-up-three-guys-at-on-the/) Wait, that title might sound wild, but it's a nod to how fighters train outside the octagon to stay sharp—think of it as an intense sparring session that builds toughness.
Adding fuel to the fire, Georges St-Pierre chimed in on TheBreakTalk, breaking down what it takes to topple someone like Makhachev. He stresses the need to handle the champion's wrestling dominance while dominating in striking exchanges—essentially, turning the tables on the Russian's powerhouse style. Masvidal's nod to Usman as a potential equal makes the fight even more enticing, controversial as it may be. St-Pierre used his teammate Mansour Barnaoui as an example; despite Barnaoui's skills, Makhachev outclassed him in a 2013 decision at M-1 Challenge 38. This illustrates the steep climb needed to challenge elite wrestlers like Makhachev, where even good grappling might not suffice without elite striking or counters.
In summary, Makhachev's push for Usman pits legacy against fresh talent in the welterweight scene, sparking debates on fairness and excitement. Is Usman the 'deserving' opponent, or should the champ face unproven but hungry fighters first? Some argue it honors past rivalries, while others see it as skipping the line—potentially devaluing the title. What do you think: Does rewarding a former champ with a rematch set a bad precedent, or is it the ultimate test of skill? Share your views in the comments—we'd love to hear if you side with Makhachev's boldness or the critics' caution. Your input could spark even more discussion!
Join Our Newsletter
Get a weekly roundup of the top Bloody Elbow stories delivered straight to your inbox
